109055 Labor dispute Cost of litigation Civil procedure code

Labor dispute

Cost of litigation

Civil procedure code art. 463, 464(1)

Proclamation no. 377/2004 art. 161

Β αŠ αŠ•α‹΅ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› ለአሠαˆͺው α‰ αˆ₯ራ ክርክር αˆαŠ­αŠ•α‹«α‰΅ α‹«α‹ˆαŒ£α‹αŠ• α‹ˆαŒ­αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ α‹¨αˆ˜αŠ­αˆαˆ αŒα‹΄α‰³ α‹¨αˆšαŒ£αˆα‰ α‰΅ α‰ αŠ­αˆ­αŠ­αˆ© α‰°αˆ¨α‰½ α‰ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘ αˆαŠ­αŠ•α‹«α‰΅ α‰₯ቻ αˆ³α‹­αˆ†αŠ• αˆ αˆ«α‰°αŠ›α‹ α‰ αŠ αˆ αˆͺው αˆ‹α‹­ α‹«α‰€αˆ¨α‰ α‹ ክሡ αˆ€αˆ°α‰°αŠ›αŠ“ α‰ α‰°αŒ­α‰ αˆ¨α‰ αˆ¨Β αˆ›αˆ΅αˆ¨αŒƒ αˆ‹α‹­ α‹¨α‰°αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰° αˆ†αŠ– ሲገኝ α‰₯ቻ αˆ΅αˆˆαˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘Β 

α‹¨αα‰΅αˆ α‰₯αˆ”αˆ­ αˆ₯ነ αˆ΅αˆ­α‹“α‰΅ αˆ…αŒ ቁαŒ₯ር 463 ፣465 (1) αŠ α‹‹αŒ… ቁαŒ₯ር 377/96 αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 161Β 

Β 

α‹¨αˆ°/መ/ቁ.109055

ሐምሌ 29 α‰€αŠ• 2007 α‹“.ም

α‹³αŠžα‰½α‘- αŠ αˆαˆ›α‹ α‹ˆαˆŒ

α‹“αˆŠ αˆ˜αˆ€αˆ˜α‹΅

α‰°αŠ½αˆŠα‰΅ α‹­αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ

αŠ α‹³αŠ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹°αˆ»α‹

α‰€αŠαŠ  α‰‚αŒ€α‰³

αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ ፑ- αŠ α‰Ά αŒŒα‰΅αŠα‰΅ αŠ¨α‰ α‹° - α‰€αˆ¨α‰‘Β Β 

α‰°αŒ αˆͺα‹Žα‰½ ፑ-Β  αˆƒα‹«α‰΅ αˆœα‹΅αŠ«αˆ αŠ¨αˆŒαŒ…Β  αŠ αˆα‰€αˆ¨α‰‘αˆα‘α‘

αˆ˜α‹αŒˆα‰‘αŠ• αˆ˜αˆ­αˆαˆ¨αŠ• α‹¨αˆšαŠ¨α‰°αˆˆα‹αŠ• ααˆ­α‹΅ ሰαŒ₯α‰°αŠ“αˆα‘α‘

ፍ  ር  α‹΅

1.Β Β Β  αŒ‰α‹³α‹© α‹¨α‰€αˆ¨α‰ α‹ α‹¨αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‹¨αŒ α‰ α‰ƒ αŠ α‰ αˆαŠ“ α‹ˆαŒ­αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ α‰₯ር 6000/αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ α‹¨α‰°αˆ°αŒ α‹ α‹αˆ³αŠ” α‰ αŠ αŒα‰£α‰‘ αŠα‹ α‹ˆα‹­αˆ΅ αŠ α‹­α‹°αˆˆαˆ? α‹¨αˆšαˆˆα‹αŠ• ጭα‰₯αŒ₯ αŠ αŒ£αˆ­α‰Ά αˆˆαˆ˜α‹ˆαˆ°αŠ• αŠα‹α‘α‘ αŒ‰α‹³α‹©αŠ• αŠ₯αŠ•α‹°αˆ˜αˆ¨αˆ˜αˆ­αŠα‹ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ« α‹αˆ‰ αŠ¨αˆ…αŒ αŠ αŒα‰£α‰₯ α‹αŒ­ α‰°α‰‹αˆ­αŒ§αˆ α‹¨αˆšαˆ ክሡ α‰ αŒα‹΄αˆ«αˆ α‹¨αˆ˜αŒ€αˆ˜αˆͺα‹« α‹°αˆ¨αŒƒ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ αŠ α‰…αˆ­α‰¦α£α‰°αŒ αˆͺ α‹¨αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ« α‹αˆ α‹¨α‰°α‰‹αˆ¨αŒ α‹ α‹¨αŠ αˆ°αˆͺαŠ“ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› αŒ‰α‹³α‹­ αŠ α‹‹αŒ… α‰ αˆšα‹°αŠαŒαŒˆα‹ αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰΅ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ• ገልጾ α‰ αˆ˜αŠ¨αˆ«αŠ¨αˆ©α£ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ­ ፍ/ቀቡ α‹¨αŒαˆ« α‰€αŠ™αŠ• ክርክር αŠ¨αˆ°αˆ› α‰ αŠƒαˆ‹ α‰°αŒ αˆͺ α‹¨αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½αŠ• α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ« α‹αˆ α‹«α‰‹αˆ¨αŒ α‹ α‰ αˆ…αŒ αŠ αŒα‰£α‰₯ αŠα‹ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ /ከሳሽ/ αˆˆα‰°αŒ αˆͺ αˆˆα‰°αŠ¨αˆ³αˆ½ α‹¨αŒ α‰ α‰ƒ αŠ α‰ αˆ α‰₯ር 5000 / αŠ αˆαˆ΅α‰΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/ αŠ₯αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ α‰₯ር 1000 /αŠ αŠ•α‹΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/ α‰ α‹΅αˆαˆ© α‰₯ር 6000 /αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/ α‹­αŠ­αˆαˆ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ α‹αˆ³αŠ” ሰαŒ₯α‰·αˆα‘α‘

2.Β Β Β  αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‰ α‹šαˆ… α‹αˆ³αŠ” α‰…αˆ­ α‰ αˆ˜αˆ°αŠ˜α‰΅ α‹­αŒα‰£αŠ α‰ αŒα‹΄αˆ«αˆ αŠ¨αα‰°αŠ› ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ፣ α‹­αŒα‰£αŠ αŠ α‰…αˆ­α‰§αˆα‘α‘ α‹¨αŒα‹΄αˆ«αˆ αŠ¨αα‰°αŠ› ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ α‰°αŠ¨αˆ³αˆ½ /α‰°αŒ αˆͺ/ αˆˆαŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‹¨αˆαˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαˆ­ αˆ›αˆ΅αŒ αŠ•α‰€α‰‚α‹« αˆ³α‹­αˆ°αŒ₯ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ« α‹αˆ‰αŠ• αŠ α‰‹αˆ­αŒ§αˆα‘α‘ αˆ΅αˆˆα‹šαˆ… መልሡ ሰጭ /α‰°αŒ αˆͺ/ αˆˆαŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‹¨αˆαˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαˆ­ α‹°αˆ˜α‹ˆα‹ α‰₯ር 10,697.96 /አሡር ሺ αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ αˆ˜α‰Ά α‹˜αŒ αŠ“ αˆ°α‰£α‰΅ α‰₯ር αŠ¨α‹˜αŒ αŠ“ αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ αˆ³αŠ•α‰²αˆ/ ግα‰₯ር α‰°α‰€αŠ•αˆΆ α‹¨αˆ˜αŠ­αˆαˆ αˆƒαˆ‹αŠαŠα‰΅ αŠ αˆˆα‰ α‰΅α‘α‘ α‰ αˆŒαˆŽα‰½ ነαŒ₯ቦች α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ­ ፍ/ቀቡ α‹¨αˆ°αŒ α‹ α‹αˆ³αŠ” αŠ αˆα‰°αŠαŠ«αˆ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ α‹αˆ³αŠ” ሰαŒ₯α‰·αˆα‘α‘

3.Β Β Β  αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ αŒ₯ር 17 α‰€αŠ• 2007 α‹“/ም α‰ α‰°αƒαˆ α‹¨αˆ°α‰ αˆ­ αŠ α‰€α‰±α‰³ α‹­αŒα‰£αŠ αˆ°αˆšα‹ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ« α‹αˆ‰ α‹¨α‰°α‰‹αˆ¨αŒ α‹ α‰ αˆ…αŒ αŠ¨α‰°α‹°αŠαŒˆαŒˆα‹ α‹αŒ­ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ• αŠ«αˆ¨αŒ‹αŒˆαŒ  α‰ αŠƒαˆ‹ α‹¨αˆαˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαˆ­ α‹°αˆ˜α‹ˆα‹ α‹¨αˆ›αˆ΅αŒ αŠ•α‰€α‰‚α‹« αŠ­αα‹« α‰₯ቻ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨αˆαˆˆαŠ α‹¨αˆ°αŒ α‹ α‹αˆ³αŠ”αŠ“ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ­ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ αˆˆα‰°αŒ αˆͺ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ α‹¨α‰°α‹ˆαˆ°αŠα‰₯αŠαŠ• α‹¨αŒ α‰ α‰ƒ αŠ α‰ αˆ αŠ₯αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ αˆ³α‹­αˆ»αˆ­ αˆ˜α‰…αˆ¨α‰± αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰³α‹Š α‹¨αˆ…αŒ αˆ΅αˆ…α‰°α‰΅ α‹«αˆˆα‰ α‰΅ αˆ΅αˆˆαˆ†αŠΒ  α‰ αˆ°α‰ αˆ­ ታይቢ α‹­α‰³αˆ¨αˆαˆαŠ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ­α‰·αˆα‘α‘ α‰°αŒ αˆͺ αŒαŠ•α‰¦α‰΅ 13 α‰€αŠ• 2007 α‹“/ም α‰ αˆ°αŒ α‹ መልሡ α‹¨αŠ αˆ°αˆͺαŠ“ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› αŒ‰α‹³α‹­ αŠ α‹‹αŒ… ቁαŒ₯ር 377/96 αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 161 αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠžα‰ΉαŠ• α‹¨α‹³αŠαŠα‰΅ αŠ­αα‹« ከመክፈል αŠαƒ α‹¨αˆšα‹«α‹°αˆ­αŒ αŠ₯αŠ•αŒ‚ α‰ αŠ αˆ°αˆͺው α‹ˆαŒ­αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹³α‹­αŠ¨ααˆ‰ α‹¨αˆšα‹«α‹°αˆ­αŒ α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒ αŠ α‹­α‹°αˆˆαˆ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ መልሡ ሰαŒ₯α‰·αˆα‘α‘ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ αŒαŠ•α‰¦α‰΅ 25 α‰€αŠ• 2007 α‹“/ም α‹¨α‰°αƒαˆ α‹¨αˆ˜αˆαˆ΅ መልሡ αŠ α‰…αˆ­α‰§αˆα‘α‘

4.Β Β Β  αŒ‰α‹³α‹© α‰ α‹šαˆ… αˆ°α‰ αˆ­ α‰½αˆŽα‰΅ α‹¨α‰°α‹«α‹˜α‹ ጭα‰₯αŒ₯ፀ የበታች ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቢች α‹¨αˆ°αŒ‘α‰΅ α‹αˆ³αŠ” α‹­α‹˜α‰΅αŠ“ ግራ α‰€αŠ™ α‹«α‰€αˆ¨α‰‘α‰΅ α‹¨αŒ½αˆα ክርክር αŠ¨αˆ‹α‹­ α‹¨α‰°αŒˆαˆˆαŒΈα‹ αˆ²αˆ†αŠ• αŠ₯αŠ›αˆ αŒ‰α‹³α‹© αˆˆα‹šαˆ… α‰½αˆŽα‰΅ αˆ²α‰€αˆ­α‰₯ α‹¨α‰°α‹«α‹˜α‹αŠ• ጭα‰₯αŒ₯ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅αˆ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ αˆˆα‰°αŒ αˆͺ α‰₯ር 6000 /αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/ α‹¨αŒ α‰ α‰ƒ αŠ α‰ αˆαŠ“ αŠͺሳራ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ የበታች ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቢች α‹¨αˆ°αŒ‘α‰΅ α‹αˆ³αŠ” α‹¨αˆ…αŒ αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰΅ αŠ αˆˆα‹ α‹ˆα‹­αˆ΅ α‹¨αˆˆα‹αˆ? α‹¨αˆšαˆˆα‹αŠ• ጭα‰₯αŒ₯ ነαŒ₯α‰₯ αˆ˜αˆ­αˆαˆ¨αŠ“αˆα‘α‘

5.Β Β Β  αŠ¨αˆ‹α‹­ α‹¨α‰°α‹«α‹˜α‹αŠ• ጭα‰₯αŒ₯ αˆˆαˆ˜α‹ˆαˆ°αŠ• αˆˆα‹«α‹αŠα‹ αŒ‰α‹³α‹­ αŠ αŒα‰£α‰₯αŠα‰΅ α‹«αˆ‹α‰Έα‹αŠ• የፍታα‰₯αˆ”αˆ­ ሡነ αˆ΅αˆ­α‹“α‰΅ αˆ…αŒ αŠ₯αŠ“ α‹¨αŠ αˆ αˆͺαŠ“ αˆ αˆ«α‰°αŠ› αŒ‰α‹³α‹­ αŠ α‹‹αŒ… ቁαŒ₯ር 377/96 α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒα‹Žα‰½ መመርመር αŠ αˆ΅αˆαˆ‹αŒŠ αŠα‹α‘α‘ α‰ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ α‰ αˆšα‹°αˆ¨αŒ ክርክር  α‰°αˆ«α‰Έα‹ αˆ΅αˆ«α‰Έα‹ αŠͺαˆ³αˆ«αŠ“ α‹ˆαŒ­ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቱ αˆŠα‹«α‹ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹°αˆšα‰½αˆαŠ“ αŠͺሳራ በቁαŒ₯ር α‹¨α‰°α‹ˆαˆ°αŠαˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαŒˆαŠ• α‹¨α‰°α‹ˆαˆ°αŠαˆˆα‰΅αŠ• የαŠͺሳራ αŒˆαŠ•α‹˜α‰₯፣ α‹¨α‹ˆαŒ­ α‹αˆ­α‹αˆ­ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹°αˆšα‹«α‰€αˆ­α‰₯ α‹¨α‰°αˆα‰€α‹°αˆˆα‰΅ α‹°αŒαˆž α‹¨α‹ˆαŒ­αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ α‹αˆ­α‹αˆ­ αŠ α‰…αˆ­α‰¦ αˆˆαˆ˜αŒ α‹¨α‰… α‹¨αˆšα‰½αˆ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ• αŠ¨αα‰΅αˆα‰₯αˆ”αˆ­ ሡነ-αˆ΅αˆ­α‹“α‰΅ αˆ…αŒ ቁαŒ₯ር 463 α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒα‹Žα‰½ α‹­α‹˜α‰΅ αˆ˜αˆ¨α‹³α‰΅ α‹­α‰»αˆ‹αˆα‘α‘ α‹­αŠΈ የαˆ₯ነ - αˆ₯αˆ­α‹“α‰΅ αˆ…αŒ‰ α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒ αŠ α‹‹αŒ… 377/96 ቁαŒ₯ር 161 αŠ•α‹‘αˆ΅ αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 2 β€œαˆ›αŠ•αŠ›α‹αˆ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› α‹ˆα‹­αˆ α‹¨αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› αˆ›αˆ…α‰ αˆ­ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ αˆˆαˆšα‹«α‰€αˆ­α‰ α‹ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ« ክርክር αŒ‰α‹³α‹­ αŠ¨αŠ­αα‹«β€ αŠαƒ αŠα‹ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ αŠ«αˆ΅α‰€αˆ˜αŒ α‹ α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒ αŒ‹αˆ­ α‰°αŒ£αŒ₯ሞ αˆ˜α‰³α‹¨α‰΅ α‹«αˆˆα‰ α‰΅ αŠα‹α‘α‘

6.Β Β Β  α‹¨αŠ α‹‹αŒ… ቁαŒ₯ር 377/96 αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 162 αŠ•α‹‘αˆ΅ αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 2 α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒ αŠ¨α‹³αŠαŠα‰΅ αŠ­αα‹« αŠαƒ αŠα‹ α‰ αˆšαˆ αˆ˜αŠ•αŒˆα‹΅ αˆ³α‹­αˆ†αŠ• β€œαŠ¨αŠ­αα‹« αŠαƒ αŠα‹β€ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ α‹¨αˆšα‹°αŠαŒαŒ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ• αŠ¨α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒα‹ αŠ α‰€αˆ«αˆ¨αŒ½αŠ“ αŠ α‹α‹΅ αŠ•α‰£α‰₯ αˆˆαˆ›α‹¨α‰΅ α‹­α‰»αˆ‹αˆα‘α‘ α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒα‹ α‹¨αŠ αˆ°αˆͺαŠ“ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› αŒ‰α‹³α‹­ αŠ α‹‹αŒ… ቁαŒ₯ር 377/96 αˆ…αŒ‹α‹ŠαŠ“ αˆ°αˆ‹αˆ›α‹Š α‹¨αŠ αˆ°αˆͺαŠ“ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› αŒαŠ•αŠ™αŠα‰΅ α‹¨αˆ˜ααŒ αˆ­α€ α‹¨αŠ’αŠ•α‹±αˆ΅α‰΅αˆͺ αˆ°αˆ‹αˆαŠ• α‹¨αˆ˜ααŒ αˆ­α€ α‰ αŠ αˆ°αˆͺαŠ“ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› መካከል α‹¨αˆšαŠαˆ³ ክርክር α‰ α‰°α‰€αˆ‹αŒ αˆ αˆ˜αŠ•αŒˆα‹΅ αˆ˜αα‰΅αˆ„ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²α‹«αŒˆαŠ α‹¨αˆ›α‹΅αˆ¨αŒ αŠ αˆ‹αˆ›α‹Žα‰ΉαŠ• α‰ αˆšα‹«αˆ³αŠ« αˆαŠ”α‰³ αˆ˜α‰°αˆ­αŒŽαˆαŠ“ ሡራ αˆ‹α‹­ αˆ˜α‹‹αˆ α‹­αŠ–αˆ­α‰ α‰³αˆα‘α‘ αŠ¨αˆ‹α‹­ α‹¨α‰°αŒˆαˆˆαŒΉα‰΅αŠ• αŠ αˆ‹αˆ›α‹Žα‰½ αˆˆαˆ›αˆ³αŠ«α‰΅α€ αˆ αˆ«α‰°αŠžα‰½ α‰ αŒαˆαˆ αˆ†αŠ α‰ αŒ‹αˆ« መα‰₯α‰³α‰½αŠ• α‰ αŠ αˆ αˆͺው α‰°αŒ₯ሢα‰₯αŠ“αˆ α‰₯αˆˆα‹ αˆ²α‹«αˆ΅α‰‘ αŒ‰α‹³α‹©αŠ• αŠ α‹­α‰Ά α‹αˆ³αŠ” ለሚሰαŒ₯ ααˆ­α‹΅ ሰጭ አካል αŠ¨αˆ…αŒ αŠ αŒα‰£α‰₯αŠ“ αˆ°αˆ‹αˆ›α‹Š α‰ αˆ†αŠ αˆ˜αŠ•αŒˆα‹΅ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²α‰³α‹­αˆ‹α‰Έα‹ αˆˆαˆ˜αŒ α‹¨α‰… α‹¨αˆšα‰½αˆ‰α‰ α‰΅αŠ• α‰°α‹°αˆ«αˆ½αŠ“ α‰€αˆαŒ£α‹ α‹¨α‹³αŠαŠα‰΅ αˆ΅αˆ­α‹“α‰΅ αˆ˜α‹˜αˆ­αŒ‹α‰΅ α‹«αˆ΅αˆαˆαŒ‹αˆα‘α‘Β 

7.Β Β Β  αŠ¨α‹šαˆ… αŠ αŠ•αƒαˆ­ αˆ²α‰³α‹­ αˆ αˆ«α‰°αŠ›α‹ α‰ αα‰΅αˆα‰₯αˆ„αˆ­ αˆ₯ነ-αˆ₯αˆ­α‹“α‰΅ αˆ…αŒ 465 αŠ•αŠ‘αˆ΅ αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 1 α‰ α‰°α‹°αŠαŒˆαŒˆα‹ αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰΅ αˆ αˆ«α‰°αŠ›α‹ αˆ€αˆ°α‰°αŠ›αŠ“ α‹¨α‰°αŒ¨α‰ αˆ¨α‰ αˆ¨ αŠ­αˆ΅αŠ“ αˆ›αˆ΅αˆ¨αŒƒ α‰ αŠ αˆ°αˆͺው αˆ‹α‹­ αˆ›α‰…αˆ¨α‰‘ αŠ«αˆα‰°αˆ¨αŒ‹αŒˆαŒ  α‰ αˆ΅α‰°α‰€αˆ­ αŠ¨αˆ…αŒ αŠ αŒα‰£α‰₯ α‹αŒ­ α‰°αŒ₯ሢα‰₯αŠ›αˆ α‹¨αˆšαˆˆα‹αŠ• α‹¨αˆ˜α‰₯ቡ αŒ₯ያቄ ለፍ/ቀቡ α‹ˆα‹­αˆ α‰ αˆ…αŒ α‹¨α‹³αŠαŠα‰΅ αˆ΅αˆαŒ£αŠ• αˆˆα‰°αˆ°αŒ α‹ አካል /አሰαˆͺαŠ“ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› α‹ˆαˆ³αŠ α‰¦αˆ­α‹΅/ αŠ α‰…αˆ­α‰¦ α‰ αˆ™αˆ‰ α‹ˆα‹­αˆ α‰ αŠ¨αŠαˆ α‰°αˆ¨α‰½ α‰ αˆ†αŠ αŒŠα‹œ αˆαˆ‰ አሰαˆͺው ለክርክሩ α‹«α‹ˆαŒ£α‹αŠ• α‹ˆαŒ­αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ α‰ αˆšα‹«αˆ΅αŒˆα‹΅α‹΅ αˆ˜αŠ•αŒˆα‹΅ α‹¨αŠ α‹‹αŒ… αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 161 α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒα‹Žα‰½ αŠ¨α‰°α‰°αˆ¨αŒŽαˆ™α‰΅ αˆ αˆ«α‰°αŠžα‰½ α‰°αŒ₯ሢα‰₯αŠ“αˆ α‹¨αˆšαˆ‰α‰΅αŠ• መα‰₯ቡ αˆˆαˆ›αˆ΅αŠ¨α‰ αˆ­ ክሡ αŠ α‰…αˆ­α‰ αŠ• α‰ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ α‰°αŠ¨αˆ«αŠ­αˆ¨αŠ• α‰₯αŠ•αˆ¨α‰³ አሰαˆͺው αˆˆαŒ α‰ α‰ƒαŠ“ ለክርክሩ α‹¨α‹ˆαŒ£α‹αŠ• α‹ˆαŒ­ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹΅αŠ•αŠ¨ααˆ αˆŠα‹ˆαˆ°αŠ•α‰₯αŠ• α‹­α‰½αˆ‹αˆ α‰ αˆšαˆ ααˆ«α‰»αŠ“ αˆ΅αŒ‹α‰΅ መα‰₯α‰³α‰Έα‹αŠ• α‰ ααˆ­α‹΅ αŠ¨αˆ˜αŒ α‹¨α‰… α‹¨αˆšαŒˆα‹°α‰‘α‰ α‰΅αŠ• αˆαŠ”α‰³ α‹¨αˆšαˆαŒ₯ር α‹­αˆ†αŠ“αˆα‘α‘ α‹­αˆ…αˆ αŠ¨αˆ‹α‹­ α‹¨αŒˆαˆˆαŒ½αŠ“α‰Έα‹αŠ• α‹¨αŠ α‹‹αŒαŠ• αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰³α‹Š α‹“αˆ‹αˆ›α‹Žα‰½ α‹¨αˆšα‹«αˆ³αŠ« αŠ α‹­α‹°αˆˆαˆα‘α‘ α‰ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αˆ αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ› ለአሰαˆͺው α‰ αˆ΅αˆ« ክርክር αˆαŠ­αŠ•α‹«α‰΅ α‹«α‹ˆαŒ£α‹αŠ• α‹ˆαŒ­αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ α‹¨αˆ˜αŠ­αˆαˆ αŒα‹΄α‰³ α‹¨αˆšαŒ£αˆα‰ α‰΅ α‰ αŠ­αˆ­αŠ­αˆ© α‰°αˆ¨α‰½ α‰ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘ αˆαŠ­αŠ•α‹«α‰΅ α‰₯ቻ αˆ³α‹­αˆ†αŠ• αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ›α‹ α‰ αŠ αˆ°αˆͺው αˆ‹α‹­ α‹«α‰€αˆ¨α‰ α‹ ክሡ αˆ€αˆ°α‰°αŠ›αŠ“ α‰ α‰°αŒ­α‰ αˆ­α‰ αˆ¨ αˆ›αˆ΅αˆ¨αŒƒ αˆ‹α‹­ α‹¨α‰°αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰° αˆ†αŠ– ሲገኝ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ• αŠ₯αŠ•α‹³αˆˆα‰ α‰΅ የፍታα‰₯αˆ”αˆ­ ሡነ αˆ΅αˆ­α‹“α‰΅ αˆ…αŒ ቁαŒ₯ር 463 α‹¨αα‰΅αˆα‰₯αˆ”αˆ­ ሡነ αˆ΅αˆ­α‹“α‰΅ αˆ…αŒ ቁαŒ₯ር 465 αŠ•α‹‘αˆ΅ αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 1 α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒα‹Žα‰½ αŠ¨αŠ α‹‹αŒ… ቁαŒ₯ር 377/96 αŠ αŠ•α‰€αŒ½ 161 α‹΅αŠ•αŒ‹αŒŒ αŒ‹αˆ­ α‰ αˆšαŒ£αŒ£αˆ αˆ˜αŠ•αŒˆα‹΅ α‰ αˆ˜α‰°αˆ­αŒŽαˆ αˆˆαˆ˜αˆ¨α‹³α‰΅ α‹­α‰»αˆ‹αˆα‘α‘

8.Β Β Β  α‰ α‹«α‹αŠα‹ αŒ‰α‹³α‹­Β  αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ αŠ¨αˆ…αŒ αŠ αŒα‰£α‰₯ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ« α‹αˆ‰ α‰°α‰‹αˆ­αŒ¦α‰₯αŠ›αˆ α‰ αˆšαˆ αŠ₯αˆαŠα‰΅ ክሡ α‹«α‰€αˆ¨α‰  αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ“ α‰ αŠ­αˆ­αŠ­αˆ­ αˆ‚α‹°α‰΅ አሰαˆͺው /α‰°αŒ αˆͺ/α‹«α‰€αˆ¨α‰ α‹ αˆ›αˆ΅αˆ¨αŒƒ αŠ¨αˆ°αˆ«α‰°αŠ›α‹ /αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½/ α‹¨α‰°αˆ»αˆˆ αˆ†αŠ– αˆ΅αˆˆα‰°αŒˆαŠ˜ α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ­ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ αˆ΅αŠ•α‰₯ቱ αˆ…αŒ‹α‹Š αŠα‹ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ α‹¨α‹ˆαˆ°αŠ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ• α‰°αˆ¨α‹΅α‰°αŠ“αˆα‘α‘ αŠ¨α‹šαˆ… α‰ α‰°αŒ¨αˆ›αˆͺ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½αŠ•αŠ“ α‹¨α‰°αŒ αˆͺαŠ• ክርክር α‰ α‹­αŒα‰£αŠ ያየው α‹¨αŒα‹΄αˆ«αˆ αŠ¨αα‰°αŠ› ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ α‰°αŒ αˆͺ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½αŠ• α‹¨αˆ΅αˆ« α‹αˆ αŠ¨αˆ›α‰‹αˆ¨αŒ‘ α‰ αŠα‰΅ α‹¨αˆαˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαˆ­ αˆ›αˆ΅αŒ αŠ•α‰€α‰‚α‹« αˆ˜αˆ΅αŒ α‰΅ αŠα‰ αˆ¨α‰ α‰΅ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ α‰°αŒ αˆͺ αˆˆαŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‹¨αˆαˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαˆ­ α‹°αˆ˜α‹ˆα‹ α‹¨αˆ›αˆ΅αŒ αŠ•α‰€α‰‚α‹« αŠ­αα‹« αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ α‹¨α‹ˆαˆ°αŠ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ• α‹­αŒα‰£αŠ αˆ°αˆšα‹ ፍ/ቀቡ αŠ¨αˆ°αŒ α‹ α‹αˆ³αŠ” α‰°αˆ¨α‹΅α‰°αŠ“αˆα‘α‘ α‹­αˆ…αˆ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‰ αŠ­αˆ­αŠ­αˆ© αˆ™αˆ‰ αˆˆαˆ™αˆ‰ α‰°αˆ¨α‰½ αŠ αˆˆαˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ•αŠ“Β  α‰ αŠ¨αŠαˆ መα‰₯ቡ α‹«αˆˆα‹ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘ α‰°αˆ¨αŒ‹αŒαŒ¦ α‹αˆ³αŠ” α‹¨α‰°αˆ°αŒ αˆˆα‰΅ αˆ˜αˆ†αŠ‘αŠ• α‹«αˆ³α‹«αˆα‘α‘

9.Β Β Β  αŠ¨αˆ‹α‹­ α‰ α‹αˆ­α‹αˆ­ αŠ¨αˆ°αŒ αŠα‹ α‹¨αˆ…αŒ α‰΅αˆ­αŒ‰αˆαŠ“ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½αŠ“ α‰°αŒ αˆͺ α‰ αˆ΅αˆ­ ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ αŠ₯αŠ“ α‰ α‹­αŒα‰£αŠ αŠ«α‰€αˆ¨α‰‘α‰΅ ክርክር αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰³α‹Š α‰£αˆ…αˆͺ αŠ αŠ•αƒαˆ­ αˆ²α‰³α‹­α£ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ αˆˆα‰°αŒ αˆͺ α‹¨αŒ α‰ α‰ƒ αŠ α‰ αˆ α‰₯ር 5000/ αŠ αˆαˆ΅α‰΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/ αŠͺሳራ α‰₯ር 1000 /αŠ αŠ•α‹΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/ α‰ α‹΅αˆαˆ© α‰₯ር 6000 /αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ የበታች ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቢች α‹¨αˆ°αŒ‘α‰΅ α‹αˆ³αŠ” αˆ˜αˆ°αˆ¨α‰³α‹Š α‹¨αˆ…αŒ αˆ΅αˆ…α‰°α‰΅ α‹«αˆˆα‰ α‰΅ αŠα‹ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαˆ΅αŠαŠ“αˆα‘α‘Β 

ው ሳ αŠ”

1. Β Β Β  α‹¨αŒα‹΄αˆ«αˆ αŠ¨αα‰°αŠ› ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ α‰ αˆ˜α‹αŒˆα‰₯ ቁαŒ₯ር 139696 α‰³αˆ…αˆ³αˆ΅ 8 α‰€αŠ• 2007 α‹“/ም α‹¨αˆ°αŒ α‹ α‹αˆ³αŠ” α‰°αˆ»αˆ½αˆαˆα‘α‘

2. Β Β Β  α‹¨αŒα‹΄αˆ«αˆ αŠ¨αα‰°αŠ› ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ α‰°αŒ αˆͺ αˆˆαŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‹¨αˆαˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαˆ­ α‹°αˆ˜α‹ˆα‹ α‰₯ር 10697.96/ አሡር ሺ αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ αˆ˜α‰Ά α‹˜αŒ αŠ“ αˆ°α‰£α‰΅ α‰₯ር αŠ¨α‹˜αŒ αŠ“ αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ αˆ³αŠ•α‰²αˆ/ ግα‰₯ር α‰°α‰€αŠ•αˆΆ αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ α‹¨αˆ°αŒ α‹ α‹¨α‹αˆ³αŠ” ክፍል αŒΈαŠ•α‰·αˆα‘α‘

3. Β Β Β  α‹¨αŒα‹΄αˆ«αˆ αŠ¨αα‰°αŠ› ፍ/ቀቡ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‰ α‰°αŒ αˆͺ α‹¨αŒ α‰ α‰ƒ αŠ α‰ αˆ α‰₯ር 5000 /αŠ αˆαˆ΅α‰΅ αˆΊαˆ… α‰₯ር/αŠͺሳራ α‰₯ር 1000 /αŠ αŠ•α‹΅ ሺ α‰₯ር/ α‰ α‹΅αˆαˆ© α‰₯ር 6000 /αˆ΅α‹΅αˆ΅α‰΅ ሺα‰₯ር/αŠ₯αŠ•α‹²αŠ¨ααˆ α‹¨αˆ°αŒ α‹ α‹¨α‹αˆ³αŠ” ክፍል α‰°αˆΈαˆ―αˆα‘α‘ αŠ αˆ˜αˆαŠ«α‰½ α‹­αˆ…αŠ•αŠ• αŒˆαŠ•α‹˜α‰₯ αˆˆα‰°αŒ αˆͺ α‹¨αˆ˜αŠ­αˆαˆ αŠƒαˆ‹αŠαŠα‰΅ α‹¨αˆˆα‰ α‰΅αˆ α‰ αˆ›αˆˆα‰΅ α‹ˆαˆ΅αŠαŠ“αˆα‘α‘

4. Β Β Β  α‰ α‹šαˆ… ααˆ­α‹΅ ቀቡ α‹«α‹ˆαŒ‘α‰΅αŠ• α‹ˆαŒ­αŠ“ αŠͺሳራ ግራ α‰€αŠ™ α‰ α‹¨αˆ«αˆ³α‰Έα‹ α‹­α‰»αˆ‰ ፑፑ

αˆ˜α‹αŒˆα‰‘ α‹ˆα‹° αˆ˜α‹αŒˆα‰₯ ቀቡ α‹­αˆ˜αˆˆαˆ΅α‘α‘

Β 

α‹¨αˆ›α‹­αŠα‰ α‰₯ α‹¨αŠ αˆαˆ΅α‰΅ α‹³αŠžα‰½ αŠαˆ­αˆ› αŠ αˆˆα‰ α‰΅α‘α‘